Skip to content
RESEARCH · QUANTUM FOUNDATIONS

When quantum observers can disagree

A recent study maps the limits of agreement.

Published Source report Sources checked
Reading tools for text size, copying, printing and your reading list
My reading list
Two observers work in labs A and B and estimate a property of a quantum system in a third lab they cannot access.
Figure 1 of the paper shows the theoretical setup. Two observers measure systems in their own labs to estimate a property of a system in a third lab.García Díaz, Brandenburger and Scarpa / PNAS

Two quantum observers can assign different probabilities without either making a calculation error. A theoretical study published online in PNAS on November 12 maps when that disagreement is possible. The work first appeared as a 2025 preprint.[1][2]

The model uses three finite-dimensional systems and local projective measurements. Both observers start from the same quantum state. Their mutual awareness is formalized as common certainty: certainty about each other’s assessments, repeated through every level.[1]

Under common certainty, when the measurements and the property being assessed commute, meaning their mathematical order can be swapped, agreement follows. A constructed example allows disagreement when one measurement does not commute with that property. The observers’ measurements still commute with each other; quantum coherence makes their conditional assessments differ.[1]

Recording outcomes in a classical register removes the relevant coherence in that example and restores agreement. The disagreement model omits observers’ beliefs about measurement order. These are mathematical results under specified information assumptions, not experimental findings.[1]

Keep your reading trail

Evidence & context

2 linked sources

Theoretical study

How to read the evidence and dates

An announcement records what an organization stated. An experiment reports an observation. A simulation or resource estimate depends on its assumptions. QubitWire’s analysis connects these sources; the labels are not quality scores.

Published is the article’s first QubitWire publication. Updated marks a substantive content change. Sources checked records a review of the underlying evidence. An older paper can support a new explanation, and another press release about the same work is not independent replication.

Sources

  1. The Quantum Agreement Theorem
  2. Preprint history
READ NEXT

Continue exploring

All Research stories
  1. Hardware

    Unwanted drive paths help suppress quantum-chip crosstalk

    A small superconducting circuit suppresses microwave crosstalk through interfering drive paths. Residual coupling limits the model’s agreement.

    Published · Source report · Sources checked · About 2 min read
  2. Quantum foundations

    One Atom, Two Paths—and a New Test of Einstein

    Researchers held one branch of an atomic wave still while another fell. Reuniting them revealed a distinctive gravitational phase.

    Published · Source report · Sources checked · About 2 min read